Halloween Carnival: Volume 2 edited by Brian James Freeman

Hydra, 2017

ISBN-13: 9780399182044

Available: Kindle edition

Spring is upon us, and that means, for me anyway, lamenting the passing of the fall and winter. In doing so, I like to read Halloween anthologies, prepping for the year’s best holiday. I originally picked these titles up on Net Galley, but I enjoyed the Halloween Carnival volumes so much that I purchased them so that I could relish the tales of the macabre throughout the year. Halloween Carnival: Volume 1 was a lovely little read, and Volume 2 is equally as good.

Five tales are contained within the pages of this book. Leading off is “Mr. Dark’s Carnival” by Glen Hirshberg. Professor R. loves Halloween, especially regarding the history of the local legend, Mr. Dark’s Carnival. Little is known about Mr. Dark, let alone the carnival itself. There are second and third hand accounts, but never, as the professor mentions in a lecture to his students, primary source accounts. The carnivals that people are invited to, by ticket only, are never the real thing—merely pranks or frat parties. Will this year be any different? He will only find out if he accepts the ticket from the body on the bridge.

“The Facts in the Case of My Sister” by Lee Thomas introduces us to young David, who loves magic, mesmerism, and hypnosis. When David’s little sister, Joyce, becomes so wracked with fear at the monsters in her closet that her screams echo the halls, he feels compelled to help her. He discovers much too late that his aid was a terrible thing to inflict on her. This story goes back and forth between adulthood and childhood and does so effectively. This is one of the strongest stories in this collection. I had to put the book down for a bit to let it sink in. I won’t ruin it, but the tension and realization of what happens because of David’s influence is dense and heartbreaking.

“Mischief Night” by Holly Newstein tells the tale of Willard, an alcoholic with a temper, and Nolan, an angry teenager from a broken home. When Nolan injures himself in his attempt to hide after a Mischief Night prank gone wrong, the two find themselves in a deadly situation.

In “The Ghost Maker” by Del James, a gangster, who is good at his job of making people disappear, answers the door to the wrong person when he’s invited to a Halloween party thrown by one of the big bosses. I think this had an interesting premise, but it wasn’t the strongest story in this collection.

“The Pumpkin Boy” by Al Sarrantonio is a chilling little story about missing children, a town legend, and the adults who struggle with their own demons while trying to make sense of the events that unfold. Jody Wendt has gone missing. Detective Len Schneider, with  perpetual doubt lingering in his mind, after he was too late during a previous case, is convinced this case will redeem him. More boys go missing in the meantime, and reports are coming in of sightings of the mysterious Pumpkin Boy.

The stories in this volume are less about gory scares than they are about psychological horror. Other than the theme of Halloween, the themes of struggle and loss permeate the tales in different ways. This is evidenced strongly in “The Facts in the Case of My Sister,” “Mischief Night,” and “The Pumpkin Boy” particularly. Recommended, especially for  fans of the Dark Screams anthologies.

Contains:

“Mr. Dark’s Carnival”: suicide

“The Facts in the Case of My Sister”: graphic description of domestic abuse

“Mischief Night”: alcoholism, death

“The Pumpkin Boy”: child abduction, child murder, gore

Reviewed by Lizzy Walker