Home » Posts tagged "reviews" (Page 2)

A Note on Review Requests

There seems to have been some confusion lately about our process for handling review requests, mainly from self-published authors, so I’m going to take this opportunity to clarify things.

MonsterLibrarian is a volunteer organization. None of us are paid for the work we do to make the site successful. The people who participate do so because they love the horror genre and horror fiction, and they want to share it with others.

Our reviewers contribute their time and energy to review books for us. Like you, they have busy lives, and reviewing for us is just one of many things they do. That they contribute reviews is a gift from them to you, to MonsterLibrarian.com, and to the genre.

We get many more review requests than we have people who can review them. When someone sends a review request to me, I look to see if it contains this essential information:

Title of the book

Author’s name

Description of the book

Yes, people do send review requests that do not include that information. If the request includes that information, I forward that on to our reviewers. Usually I will let the person know when I have done that. If the review request interests or intrigues a reviewer, and they have the time and energy to do so, they tell me they would like to review the book, and I write the author back with that information.

Note those words “interests and intrigues”.  The description of the book included in the review request can make a difference. If I send out a request for review describing a book as  “a collection of  horror short stories”,  it’s probably not going to grab anyone.  Try to be more specific.

I will also note that a polite and professionally written request is much more likely to snag someone’s interest, although I can’t make any guarantees.

I’d love to see every book get reviewed, but it’s just not possible. We do our best.

Just in case I missed something here, I have a special page just for authors with a Q&A about the site. Here’s a link.

 

 

 

Scary Movies: Taking The Kids to Pacific Rim

 

I’m going to confess it. I am not a fan of most of the recent horror or monster movies (with the exception of Cabin in the Woods). There’s just too much splat and gore for me. But in this house there’s no escaping kaiju movies (for the uninitiated, that’s Godzilla and friends). My husband has loved them since he was a kid and he has loved sharing them with our kids. As scary movies go, they’re not too terrifying. I mean, how scary can a guy in a rubber suit really be, especially when you’re sitting in Daddy’s lap?

Movies today are a different story. CGI effects allow moviemakers to make truly frightening creatures that actually look like they could be real. There aren’t many kaiju books, and really, with kaiju, the moving picture is worth a thousand words. And movies today have a lot more foul language, sexual content, and graphic violence. With Daddy desperate to see Pacific Rim, the brand new kaiju movie, on opening weekend, the question became, with two kaiju loving kids who also dart from the room anytime they sense potential violence onscreen, should we take them to see Pacific Rim? The reviewer at Dread Central said, “This is a movie for everyone! Bring your kids”! (see the entire review here) Geek parents on Facebook told me it was a great movie for geek kids, depending on the kid. Movie Mom loved it but brought up that there was intense violence and mild profanity (see her review here). Common Sense Media also mentioned the intense violence and suggested it for ages 12 and older (review here). And it is a movie rated PG-13. My kids are 6 and 7. Would the “intense violence” overwhelm their excitement about seeing a brand-new kaiju movie with their dad? We decided to risk it. Was it worth it? Absolutely. They were swept away by the battles between the giant robots and giant monsters. In fact, on reflection, my daughter(who kept her eyes tightly closed during the bear scene in Brave) said she loved the “cool” glowing monster tongues. Frankly, I was more concerned about what they saw in the trailers that preceded the movie than what was in the movie itself.

I loved it too, and that’s really saying something. While I deeply admire the original Godzilla movie, I have a big problem with the representation of women as mainly love interests or passive victims in most of the early science fiction and horror movies. But while this movie failed the Bechdel test. it did have one of the most awesome female characters I have seen in a long time. It is true that I don’t get out to the movies much, but Mako Mori is my new favorite character in monster movies. In spite of an overprotective father figure and her own traumatic memories, Mako Mori is one of a very few pilots, the best in the world, who save humanity from extinction by giant monster. And she does it without ever getting romantically involved with her opposite-sex partner. While it’s implied at the end of the movie that a romance may devleop, she and her partner make it through the entire movie, working together and sharing memories and feelings, without even a kiss. I’m in love with Mako Mori, and my daughter saw a hero, a capable woman, who helped to save the world.

When you are considering taking your kids out to a movie that has monsters or extreme violence, I think it’s really important to consult multiple sources (I wouldn’t have used any of the three reviews I cited above on its own to make the decision), and to know your kids well enough to make the decision about whether to take them. You can’t depend on movie ratings for much, anymore. Had this movie had extreme gore or “adult situations” we would never have considered taking the kids. But it is worth the time to research it, if you have a monster-loving family.

MonsterLibrarian.com Review of The Undead and Theology Published By Examiner.com

If you visit our site frequently, and I hope you do, you know that we just wrapped up a big review project on the Stoker nominees of 2013. In 2012, for the first time, we decided to review as many of the Stoker nominees as we could. Many of the writers and publishers of nominated books sent us review copies and our hardworking reviewers took on the challenge of getting as many reviewed as possible. This year we decided to do it again. Lisa Morton at the HWA notified nominees that we planned to review Stoker nominees, and we received review copies from many of the writers and publishers. Our final reviews for the Stoker 2013 project went up in June before the Stokers were awarded.

One of the Stoker nominees in the nonfiction category was The Undead and Theology, edited by Kim Paffenroth and John W. Morehead. This is an anthology of essays by academics on the topic indicated by the title, published by Pickwick Publications, an imprint of independent publisher Wipf and Stock. Having just written an essay for an anthology of essays by academics myself, I can tell you that it doesn’t pay much to write for one, and copies are expensive and not handed out to just anyone. So we were very pleased to receive a review copy of this book! Reviewer Colleen Wanglund read and reviewed The Undead and Theology for us, and recommended it for purchase by libraries.

I am pleased to say that Colleen’s review has now been picked up by Examiner.com, where hopefully an entirely new audience will be reached. Reviews matter, especially for niche academic titles, and the more people who know about a great book, and want to read it, the better. Take a moment and check out the review, and reviews for some of the other nonfiction titles we’ve done in the past. Best wishes to everyone involved!